Skip to main content

Renters Are Staying Longer: What Jacksonville Investors Should Know

Renters Are Staying Longer: What Jacksonville Investors Should Know

Across the country, renters are moving less frequently than they once did. For rental property investors, this shift could have a significant impact on vacancy rates, turnover expenses, and long-term investment performance.

According to Harvard University's Joint Center for Housing Studies, just 11.2% of U.S. households moved in 2024, the lowest household mobility rate recorded in the American Community Survey.

Renters are also staying in their homes longer. A Redfin analysis of U.S. Census data found that 33.6% of renters had lived in the same property for at least five years, compared to 28.4% a decade earlier.

So, what's driving this trend, and what does it mean for landlords and real estate investors?

Why Are Renters Staying Longer?

Several factors are contributing to longer rental stays, but housing affordability is one of the biggest.

Higher home prices, mortgage interest rates, and the costs associated with purchasing a home have made the transition from renting to owning more challenging.

According to the National Association of REALTORS®, first-time homebuyers represented just 22% of buyers in its 2026 report, while the median age of first-time buyers remained at a record high of 40.

For many renters, homeownership is becoming a longer-term goal rather than an immediate next step.

Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York reinforces this trend. Between 2014 and 2026, renters' average perceived probability of moving within the next three years declined from approximately 57% to 37%.

Interestingly, renters haven't necessarily lost interest in homeownership. Many still want to purchase a home but face financial obstacles that make renting their most practical option.

Lease Renewals Are Becoming Increasingly Important

The shift toward longer rental stays is also reflected in lease renewal activity.

According to CBRE's 2026 U.S. Real Estate Market Outlook, renewals account for approximately 57% of all apartment leasing activity, compared to 51% in 2015 and 48% in 2005.

For rental property investors, this presents an opportunity to focus on tenant retention rather than relying exclusively on attracting new tenants.

Every successful renewal can help reduce the expenses associated with preparing and leasing a vacant property.

Why Longer Tenant Stays Can Benefit Investors

1. Reduced Vacancy Loss

Every day a rental property sits vacant represents potential lost income.

For example, a property renting for $1,500 per month that remains vacant for 30 days loses approximately $1,500 in potential rental revenue.

Keeping a reliable tenant in place can reduce the frequency of these interruptions.

2. Lower Turnover Expenses

When a tenant moves out, landlords may face expenses such as cleaning, painting, repairs, landscaping, advertising, and leasing fees.

Some turnovers require only minor work, while others can become expensive depending on the property's condition.

Reducing unnecessary turnover can help protect an investment property's profitability.

3. More Predictable Cash Flow

A long-term tenant who consistently pays rent and maintains the property can provide investors with greater income stability.

Predictable rental income makes it easier to budget for maintenance, insurance, property taxes, and future capital improvements.

4. Reduced Leasing and Administrative Work

Finding a new tenant requires marketing, showings, applications, screening, lease preparation, and move-in coordination.

While these responsibilities can be handled by a professional property management company, they still represent time and expenses associated with operating an investment property.

What About the Jacksonville Rental Market?

Although the national trend points toward longer rental stays, individual markets can behave differently.

Redfin's analysis of 2023 Census data found that 8.8% of Jacksonville-area renters had lived in the same home for at least 10 years, compared with 7.6% a decade earlier.

The same analysis found that 32.4% of Jacksonville-area renters had been in their current home for less than one year.

These figures illustrate why investors should consider both national housing trends and local market conditions when developing their rental strategies.

Jacksonville's rental market has its own supply, demand, pricing, and neighborhood differences. A strategy that works in one area may not produce the same results in another.

Tenant Retention Should Be Part of Every Investor's Strategy

While longer tenant stays can benefit landlords, retaining tenants isn't simply a matter of offering a renewal.

Rental property owners should consider several factors when making renewal decisions:

• Competitive rental pricing: Evaluate local rental comparables before proposing increases.
• Timely maintenance: Address repair requests and keep the property in good condition.
• Proactive communication: Begin renewal discussions early enough to plan for either an extension or a vacancy.
• Property condition: Conduct appropriate inspections and address maintenance concerns before they become larger expenses.
• Tenant performance: Consider payment history, lease compliance, and overall tenancy when evaluating renewals.

It is also important to balance tenant retention with the property's financial performance. Rising insurance premiums, property taxes, and maintenance expenses may still require reasonable rent adjustments.

The goal isn't necessarily to keep a tenant at any cost. It's to make informed decisions that support both the tenant relationship and the property's long-term profitability.

The Bottom Line for Rental Property Investors

The rental market is evolving, and longer tenant stays may become an increasingly important part of successful rental property ownership.

For investors, fewer turnovers can mean lower operating expenses, reduced vacancy exposure, and more consistent rental income.

However, a strong rental investment strategy requires more than simply keeping a property occupied. It requires competitive pricing, preventive maintenance, effective communication, and careful financial management.

At Thirdstone Properties, we understand that protecting an investment means looking beyond monthly rent collections. Our Jacksonville property management team works with rental property owners to make informed leasing, renewal, and maintenance decisions that support their long-term investment goals.

Whether you own one rental property or an entire portfolio, a proactive property management strategy can make a meaningful difference.

Own rental property in Jacksonville? Contact Thirdstone Properties to learn how our property management services can help protect and grow your investment.

---

Sources

1. [Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies – Household Mobility Fell to Record Low in 2024](https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/household-mobility-fell-record-low-2024)
2. [Redfin – America's Renters Are Moving Less Than Ever](https://www.redfin.com/news/renter-tenure-2024/)
3. [CBRE – U.S. Real Estate Market Outlook 2026: Multifamily](https://www.cbre.com/insights/books/us-real-estate-market-outlook-2026/multifamily)
4. [National Association of REALTORS® – 2026 First-Time Home Buyer Report](https://www.nar.realtor/newsroom/first-time-home-buyer-share-inches-up-to-22-median-age-remains-at-record-high-of-40)
5. [Federal Reserve Bank of New York – Why Do Fewer Renters Expect to Move?](https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2026/08/why-do-fewer-renters-expect-to-move/)

*National research and historical Jacksonville-area data are presented for educational purposes. Individual investment performance and local rental conditions will vary.*

back